During seminary I was summoned for jury duty. Without question, I was immediately scratched by one side. I asked a friend the rejected playground question of my childhood: “Why wasn’t I picked? What’s wrong with me?” My friend said, “Probably your seminary address; lawyers figure ministers are strong-willed thinkers. They want to be able to sway a juror to see things their way.”
I lived under that baseless theory for thirty years until I was summoned with 60 people for jury duty. Even though I made sure I proclaimed my vocation was ministry, I still was one of “the chosen” — though I wasn’t fully convinced I wanted to be.
The trial wasn’t a white-collar crime; it concerned violence. Various body-camera views from officers called to the scene were edited and shown. One victim testified the violence wasn’t that bad; her son was really a good boy. The accused man took the stand to have his say.
We the jury seemed to spend more time in the break room while the lawyers and judge met, than we did in the courtroom. I almost finished the book I had been invited to bring in the summons letter.
The judge gave us written instructions about options the law gave for various degrees of guilt or innocence. I was elected jury foreperson because I had a career of running meetings where every side was heard. That was the first I learned how the other jurors reacted to what they heard. After clearing up three questions, we became unanimous in deciding the severity of the crime. We ordinary people in an alien environment made a decision that led a judge to sentence a man. I was disturbed (and made a little afraid) by the man’s eyes looking to blame everyone in that room (except himself).
I received a gift I wish more jurors could receive — confirmation that dispelled uncertainty. In the parking lot, an observer told two of us we had made the right decision. When we were out, the defense made sure the body-cam footage was highly edited so we didn’t hear officers mentioning previous encounters. Other evidence was suppressed as too prejudicial. She said, “If you research his past cases and sentences, you’d learn this wasn’t his first time, and I hope you helped make it his last. Thank you for your service.” I was thanked for playing a part in a system of justice that worked.
What roles have you played in our system of justice? When you say the Pledge of Allegiance — with “liberty and justice for all” — who does the “all” include? What does the promise of “liberty and justice for all” mean to you?